Skip to main content

American Auschwitz: Trump’s “Final Solution” to the Immigrant Question

Only two months into his presidency and Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winning playwright Robert Schenkkan’s Building the Wall imagines Trump’s plans to “solve” the “problem” of the millions of undocumented immigrants living in America in this world premiere ripped from the proverbial headlines. ​

Editors' Note: We saw "Building The Wall" Sunday afternoon and most highly recommend that you catch it before it closes at the Fountain Theatre in late August. We're updating Ed Rampell's review of the play from last March. Four more months of the Trump Administration have only made this play more chillingly relevant. Since Ed's review, Victoria Platt has replaced Judith Moreland in the role of Gloria.—Dick Price & Sharon Kyle

BUILDING THE WALL Theatre Review

building the wall

Victoria Platt and Bo Foxworth

The response to Trump and his polices are flying fast and furious from the creative community. Only two months into his presidency and Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winning playwright Robert Schenkkan’s Building the Wall imagines Trump’s plans to “solve” the “problem” of the millions of undocumented immigrants living in America in this world premiere ripped from the proverbial headlines. ​

The entire one act two-hander takes place in the visiting room of a prison where Gloria (Victoria Platt replacing Judith Moreland), an African American history professor, has received hard-to-get permission to interview Rick (Bo Foxworth), a Caucasian, tattooed inmate in an orange uniform. (I guess orange really is the new Black!) The play opens with lots of back and forth: will he/won’t he? talk about what sounds like a heinous crime Rick has been convicted of and may face the death sentence for.

After this tap dance goes on a bit too long they finally get down to brass tacks and Rick tells his side of the story. As the veteran unspools his tale, I thought that as a true Trump believer, Rick - who worked security for The Donald and met him during his campaign - had gone postal and gunned down “illegal” aliens during a shooting spree. But as Gloria relentlessly presses the prisoner, something far more nefarious emerges.

Only two months into his presidency and Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winning playwright Robert Schenkkan’s Building the Wall imagines Trump’s plans to “solve” the “problem” of the millions of undocumented immigrants living in America.

When sweeping, widespread deportation plans are frustrated by countries simply refusing to open up their borders, the Trump junta resorts to “Plan B.” Enter Rick, who ends up playing a key role in a secretive “final solution” to the immigrant question of Hitlerian proportion. With references to gas chambers and ovens, Rick participates in the mass extermination of undocumented people who have entered and stayed in the good ol’ USA without their prerequisite papers.

Throughout the 90-minute or so show performed without intermission Rick comes across not as a heartless mass murderer but as a conflicted man caught in a conundrum. As the Nazi war criminals at the Nuremberg Tribunals said, Rick “was just following orders.” But unlike Hogan’s Heroes’ Colonel Klink, Rick can’t claim, “I know nothing.”

The acting is excellent throughout as Gloria alternately cajoles, consoles, confronts, condemns, scolds, etc., Rick in her relentless drive for the truth that reveals as much about this academic as it does the jumpsuit-ed inmate. What I thought was the ultimate, inevitable outburst and explosion never happens - Rick simmers, rather than blows his top. Nevertheless, well-directed by Michael Michetti, the thesps acquit themselves admirably in a format that is dramatically difficult.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended for You

In essence, Schenkkan’s script has two people talking to each other in a room. They are committing one of drama’s biggest sins: “Telling” instead of “showing” what happens. This is a problem similar to that of Citizenfour, wherein Edward Snowden sits in a hotel room telling a few reporters and answering their questions about NSA’s overreaching mass surveillance throughout most of the documentary. No matter how compelling a saga may be, in visual and performing arts, it’s far more dramatic and gripping for the story to be shown, not just told. I noticed some audience members had trouble following this verbal tour-de-force.

Another problem is that Gloria does not merely play the role of an objective historian - or journalist, for that matter. She is very partisan, and her questions cover well trod ground about Hillary Clinton and so on that seem calculated to generate conflict.

Be that as it may, Schenkkan’s is a brave voice warning us about what may occur in the near future, just as Sinclair Lewis’ It Can’t Happen Here anti-fascist novel adapted as a play in 1936 was. Among other things, the play alludes to a Reichstag Fire type of trumped-up calamity that enables the Trump junta to suspend constitutional rights and liberties, which really is something we should all be on the lookout for in the months to come.

John Nobori’s sound design occasionally makes a nod to the prison beyond the visiting room. The set is sparse but Se Oh’s design is clever: What may be a one-way window is also a mirror, and in addition to the two characters, members of the audience are glimpsed in reflections. This, visually, may express a notion of mass guilt - how complicit are Americans in the elevation of a fascistic tweethead to the presidency? (Yes, I know about three million more Americans voted for Clinton, but Hitler rose to power in elections he likewise scored a minority of votes in. The fault is in systems that need to be changed by the masses of people in order to reflect truly popular will. And those who don’t take action are arguably guilty of at least compliance, the mirror suggests.)

If this is Trump’s honeymoon period, just imagine what the divorce will look like. The trajectory he and his junta are on is completely unsustainable. One thing’s certain: It’s not going to end well. In Wall Schenkkan imagines what happens to Il Presidente - but for my money, Trump will end up like the dictator he tweets quotes from and most resembles: Mussolini.

Building theWall is being performed through August 25 on Thursdays, Fridays, Saturdays and Mondays at 8:00 p.m.; Sundays at 2:00 p.m. at the Fountain Theatre, 5060 Fountain Ave., Los Angeles CA 90029. For more info: (323)663-1525 or www.FountainTheatre.com. This is the first in a series of productions set to take place at theaters across the U.S. as part of a National New Play Network Rolling World Premiere.

Ed Rampell

Film historian/reviewer Ed Rampell is co-presenting Sergei Eisenstein’s revolutionary classic Battleship Potemkin on Friday, 7:30 p.m., March 24, 2017 at The L.A. Workers Center, 1251 S. St. Andrews Place, L.A., CA 90019. For info: laworkersedsoc@gmail.com.